Contexts quicklit: baseball sociology
Happy opening day! Although technically the first game of the season was played yesterday, today marks the first day of the 2015 baseball season for the other 28 major league baseball teams. It’s a good time to consider what we can learn by applying a sociological lens to the sport. Baseball provides an opportunity for sociologists to study many facets of society. In fact, a search for baseball in the JSTOR database of sociology journals produces 2,819 results.
This past year, the National Football League brought increased focus to sociological topics such as domestic violence, the relationship between head trauma, masculinity, and health, heteronormativity, racist slurs, and most recently, occupational segregation. So, what sociological lessons can we learn from the study of baseball?
Baseball is known as America’s “favorite pastime,” making it an interesting area to investigate nationalism. Baseball was used as a symbol of American values in World War II and in 1950, Jack Holden and Frances Kay’s song promoting patriotism during the Cold War included the lyrics, “We love our baseball and apple pie / We love our country fair / We’ll keep Old Glory waving high / There’s no place here for a bear.” Although the U.S. national anthem is played before the start of every game, the players come from all over the world, especially Venezuela and the Dominican Republic. (Munenori Kawasaki, a Japanese baseball player, out of respect for his team undertook learning the lyrics to the national anthem while playing for the Seattle Mariners – only to be traded to the Toronto Blue Jays and learning O Canada.) Baseball is also a foreign policy football, as with recent changes in the recruitment of Cuban players.
The signing of Jackie Robinson to the Dodgers in 1946 was a sign of racial progress in America and has received much scholarly attention (that’s why the figure starts in 1947). However, racial inequality in baseball manifests in a multitude of ways and has been the primary focus of sociologists who study the sport. Sociologists have analyzed the rise and then decline of African American players, they have studied racial salary differentials (finding no difference) and career longevity (shorter for Blacks), and documented how management and broadcasting positions are disproportionately White. Changes in race relations in the U.S. and economic conditions are associated with differing racial composition of teams and variations in starting line-ups. A large sociological literature shows that African American players are marginalized through placement in non-central positions. From massive new data available on pitches, we’ve learned that umpires are more likely to widen the strike zone for White pitchers.
Cathedrals of Consumption
Stadiums are prime spots to study cathedrals of consumption, sociologist George Ritzer’s label for places that enchant us to consume. At games, fans become part of the spectacle by cheering on teams, singing along to music, and engaging in provided audience games. Each year teams promote lavish new food to consume while visiting their ballpark. The games have become increasingly commercialized with seemingly every part of the game sponsored, from Coors Light Silver Bullet instant-replay to the Colorado Rockies’ deal with Taco Bell to give residents free tacos every time the Rockies score at least 7 runs.
Similar to the NFL, Major League Baseball provides ample opportunity to learn about gender. Women sidelined in the role of “ball girl” (check out this 1991 New York Times gem on the emergence of ball girls). MLB’s pairing of breast cancer awareness and Mother’s Day celebrations (complete with pink bats) is some sort of statement on gender. Additionally, changing expectations of men’s roles as fathers have emerged in discussions of players’ paternity leave. Although the NFL is just recently attending to domestic violence, accountability for male players’ actions and modeling respect for women has been an ongoing conversation in baseball, at least for some teams.
Although some may find the sport too slow paced to be entertaining, Paul Richards described baseball as “a beautifully put together pattern of countless little subtleties that finally add up to the big moment, and you have to be well-versed in the game to truly appreciate them.” Maybe mastering baseball fandom is good practice for developing the sociological imagination.
Follow Joanna Pepin at @CoffeeBaseball.