The case for seeing your Trump-voting family this holiday season

Photo: Ari Helminen https://flic.kr/p/7Gbuqn
Family dinner. Photo: Ari Helminen https://flic.kr/p/7Gbuqn

Three members of my immediate family voted for Trump.

I generally avoid political discussions with my family because it seems unproductive and makes holidays unpleasant. I left the Thanksgiving table in 2008 when one of my uncles wouldn’t stop making derogatory remarks about then president-elect Obama. Over the years, I’ve learned it’s easier to spend our limited time together in relative harmony, even if that means discussion is relegated to somewhat superficial topics and niceties. As a Michigan native who now calls Washington, D.C. home, this dynamic is heightened in the Midwest as our ethos is one of politeness. While I was vaguely aware that I had family members voting for Trump, I did not discuss it with them prior to the election, partly because it seemed irrelevant in light of the fact that Clinton would likely win, and partly because I knew the conversation would be uncomfortable.

There has been an abundance of online sharing through blogs and social media as people write open letters to their Trump-voting and conservative, Christian family members. While these letters may or may not actually be read by the authors’ families, many people will be gathering with their relatives during the upcoming holiday season. I happened to have a previously-scheduled trip home to Michigan the weekend after the election, and I approached it with anxiety. As someone who was ensconced in my own echo chamber of intellectual and progressive folks, I joined the crowd of those shocked and dismayed by the election results. I struggled to reconcile how the family that raised me could vote against so many of my ideals. I knew I needed to have this uncomfortable conversation with them.

So, three days after the election, we had the talk. My dad, who is a therapist, suggested that we identify the goals of the conversation and what each of us hoped to get out of it prior to actually having the discussion. This was very helpful. I tried really hard to (mostly) listen. As an academic, and as a sociologist in particular, we are trained to be critical thinkers, to identify how structures and institutions shape lived experiences, and often come armed with empirical analysis. These conversations with our family members are not the time for lectures or recitation of facts, however well informed. I learned more about how my parents – who in many ways have relatively liberal stances on social issues – ended up voting the way they did. They expressed dismay at the liberal “moral outrage” directed at those who voted for Trump. I shared the personal and collective pain that had emanated from my social circles as friends and colleagues legitimately fear for their well-being. Learning happened in all sorts of ways: My Dad referenced some of my Tweets; I didn’t even know he was on Twitter. Our conversation was hard. I cried a lot.

But one of my biggest takeaways from this difficult conversation was the “othering” that I think is occurring by those on the left about Trump voters. While I can easily recognize othering and discuss the reasons for homophily – the tendency to spend time and form relationships with those similar to ourselves – from a theoretical perspective, it can be harder to identify it in our personal lives. The newsfeed of my own social media is full of memes, articles, and posts focusing on the White supremacist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, and oppressive ideals that a Trump vote supposedly represents. It’s very easy to quickly lump all Trump voters together, and especially if you are not engaging with actual Trump voters, this is easy to continue propagating. What I heard from my family is that this rhetoric is not doing anything to further the progressive cause; instead it’s contributing to their feeling of alienation from liberal elites and contributing to polarization.

I have a former supervisor who regularly reminded me that social change is only going to happen through relationships. While it’s cathartic to engage in social media activism, and lament all the ways I’m very concerned about the ripple effects of how Trump’s win normalizes oppressive behavior, I’m mostly talking to people who already agree with me. What if I had truly engaged with my family about these topics prior to the election? It may not have changed their vote, but it would have facilitated dialogue in which we each gained more understanding about the many perspectives that exist. My family members and I agree on some things; what if we talked about how to make those ideals a reality?

I know people who have canceled their Thanksgiving and holiday plans because they have had fallings-out with their Trump-voting family members. I respect and empathize with this. At the same time, there’s a lot of power in being in relationship with others. Taking off our “expert” academic hats, getting outside of our intellectual and likeminded echo chambers, and really listening and sharing with people we love who have divergent viewpoints can be illuminating. There’s historical precedence for this; when people began coming out of the closet, it turned a corner for the LGBTQ movement: having a personal relationship with someone LGBTQ made it harder to vote against their interests and support regressive policies. The same holds true as we face this post-Obama era. These conversations can happen in a number of ways, but we need to humanize and be in relationship with those who voted differently than us.

Comments 13

Jacqui

November 21, 2016

Loved reading this, Brittany! Thank you for writing and sharing your experience.


Robert Francis

November 22, 2016

Thanks for this thoughtful reflection! As someone in very similar shoes, I appreciate all you shared. Like you, I assumed Clinton would win so did not engage my rural Pennsylvania family pre-election like I might have. And whether or not it would have changed a vote, I would have been well served to stretch myself and speak across difference.


henry

October 18, 2018

So this is the best thing we can get now here. ccnumbers.net


Rick Jones

January 22, 2020

Thank you for this lovely post! Your style of writing is amazing. Once I graduate from University, I would like to become an expert in educational sphere. I hope to do that this year with the help of an academic writing AU Assignment Help company that has a team of professional writers who work on my papers. Feel free to check their official website assignment-help-au.com for more information and contact the Support team that is available 24/7.


George J. Oles

May 27, 2020

Thank you for an amazing and astonishing post which you have posted on the page. Your style of writing is very good and brillassignment.co.uk help individual to gain quality work. Words are arranged smoothly in a very good manner. I liked the article very much. Keep sharing more articles like this.


Lisa King

August 11, 2020

Thank you for this lovely post. Loved reading it. EssayKing.co.uk also posts such creative content. I highly appreciate your writing skills. Also thank you for sharing your experience with us.


Linda Jason

August 18, 2020

It's such an amazing article you shared with us! Phd dissertation appreciate you for making that kind of kind of content.


King Alisah

September 4, 2020

I truly appreciate basically perusing the majority of your article content. Just needed to advise you that you have dissertation introduction individuals like me who value your work with amazing content. Thank you so much :)


Elizabeth03

September 11, 2020

Head over to this website to find an answer to your question. We'll offer the best solution. Just read an article we've written for you.


King Alisah

September 14, 2020

Thanks for sharing your articles and, I really appreciate your knowledgeable tips and, I will be waiting for your Assignment Help Melbourne further post thank you once again and share more updates for us.


Jessica Byrne

September 14, 2020

It is very unique topic you’ve written here. The fact Assignment Help Perth remains I’m not really acquainted with this, nevertheless I think this is a great opportunity to find out more about this topic. Thanks buddy.


Jessica Byrne

September 14, 2020

Some truly fantastic articles on this internet, I appreciate assignment help in australia it for contribution and This kind of information is great and so useful for me. bye and good night admin


markk burnett

September 25, 2020

I am a Beauty Blogger I loves to Read and writes about Beauty and haircare products.for more beauty products please go ThroughHow to Make My Hair Stronger?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *