On Scholarly Activism
The moment before you are served up to an audience as the attraction for the next hour is always a stressful time. Worried about whether you will be as cogent and articulate as planned and wondering if the technology will work properly is enough to occupy yourself during the verbal introductions and formalities. But during the last year of speaking engagements, I’ve faced an additional unexpected twinge of nervousness. It happens when the person describing my biography utters the words, “Sara is a scholar-activist.”
As I watch the room and see people shift in their seats, with some academics offering a slight smirk or scowl, I sometimes rethink the decision to amend my online biography to begin in this way. I rise to talk, usually about college affordability, wondering if my credibility has eroded as the phrase was spoken aloud. But I have found that as I move through the talk, as I describe the powerful ways societal inequities have reshaped the role of higher education over the last forty years and how opportunities for students have suffered, I become increasingly convinced again that I want to bear the label.
Scholarly activism is not advocacy. Let me say that again, since in my experience people have trouble hearing this. I am a scholar-activist, but not an advocate. The difference is critical. An advocate begins with a core and guiding goal—not a theory—and pushes for changes to achieve that goal. In contrast, a scholar-activist begins with a set of testable assumptions, subjects these to rigorous research, and once in possession of research findings seeks to translate those findings into action. With much respect to my colleagues working in advocacy, I much prefer the latter role since I often have more unanswered questions than clear goals, prefer to turn to data rather than personal beliefs when thinking through policy options, and find that actions are more effective when guided by research.
But for some reason, despite numerous calls (both internal and external) for more scholars to become engaged in discussions about real life problems, many in the academy continue to downplay the work of scholars who act on their findings. Those who instead study a topic, reach conclusions, and place their results into a journal without doing anything else about them stand in higher regard. This strikes me as a major limitation of social science as a field, and one that threatens our future.
A public agenda of scholarly activism brings the lessons of scholarship into the real lives of communities. It challenges even the most extroverted academic to become clearer about her ideas, more thoughtful about how she communicates them, and wiser about how she evaluates the merits of research. It is far more difficult to be a scholar-activist, in my experience, than note to be one. It takes time, energy, emotional labor, and a thick skin. It is usually an unpaid gig.
Last year I not only rethought my biography but also acted more boldly than before, opening a translational research laboratory focused on making college affordable. The Wisconsin HOPE Lab builds on my last decade of research and the studies of many academics around the country. Our mission is to conduct rigorous research that can in turn guide action. Not only that, but our core operating budget allows us to engage directly in that action, helping colleges and universities, policymakers, and community groups to make changes to their practices in order to diminish inequality. As a sociologist, it is a great relief to move beyond teaching and writing about social stratification and finally get my hands dirty to ameliorate the conditions themselves. What I learn from doing leads to new research ideas, lends shades of grey to my current theories, and helps me identify appropriate partners for the next stages of my work.
Here is an example. Over the past six years my research team has spent a great deal of time learning about the struggles that some students from low-income families face when it comes to affording enough food. We explored this issue, first revealed in interviews, using surveys and more interviews, and then turned to administrative data to see if and how policies and practices about living costs at colleges and universities might play a role. We initiated two scholarly papers on the topic, both issued as working papers this fall. In addition, in June we convened a workshop of policymakers and practitioners to talk about how they are addressing food insecurity on their campuses, what challenges students face, and what unanswered questions they have. This led me to connect with Clare Cady, a practitioner who leads the College and Universities Food Bank Alliance. Clare’s presentation at our workshop made me aware of the significant institutional challenges that can occur in addressing food insecurity on campus; this expanded the thinking I had engaged in while previously studying the sites involved with Single Stop USA, another nonprofit. This affected how I am now working with student groups locally in Madison to bring a food pantry to our campus, and how I have spoken with reporters about the findings of our research. It also affected how I have worked with and advised an undergraduate who has spent much of the last five years homeless while attending UW-Madison. In turn, she has taught me about the ways that students can be isolated from the numerous services provided on and off campus; dimensions of the next stages of my work that will receive more exploration. Indeed, attempting to act to create the changes that the work of my Lab reveal are needed has helped me develop the next stage of the research.
These are the thoughts that flicker through my mind now when the formal introductions commence and I am yet again announced as a “scholar-activist.” I am working hard to embrace with pride this role and this life, in the hopes that many others will follow in my footsteps.
Sara Goldrick-Rab is Professor of Educational Policy Studies and Sociology the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Follow her on Twitter at @saragoldrickrab.
Comments 41
Anthony Hernandez
December 4, 2014You're an inspiration!
Amy L, Proietti
December 5, 2014Sara,
I hope yours is the start of a transformation into scholar-activism as a norm in the social sciences. Your work is pioneering and also personally impactful for me as a financial aid and student services professional.
I appreciate the delineation between advocacy and scholar-activism. We need both, but to move the conversation forward in effective ways, we need more scholar-activists, followed by proven methods for the two to engage together in change.
As I've tweeted to you before, reading your work almost makes me want to go for that PhD. Almost.
Thank you for all you do.
--Amy P.
Isaac Youcha
December 5, 2014Talking the talk is not enough. Some one has to do God's work. Applying scientific reseach to help others is acceptable in the physical sciences and you are following that tradition. Keep it up, we need more like you if we are going to have a thriving nation.
Tiffanie L-D
December 12, 2014Dr. Goldrick-Rab, I have a lot of respect for you as a scholar and, now I know, as a scholar-activist. But, can I provide a bit of critique- the insinuation that advocates are without questions or research before they take action is not completely true. Our research looks different than that conducted in the ivory tower. Qualitative in nature- I see through each day what is happening and realize public schools (K-12) some issues are systemic and affecting more than just a few, I take action and advocate for change at the decision-making level. To me, that is research although not the kind accepted by journals like AERJ. I applaud all the hard work you do, but as an advocate and a scholar, I think we have to be careful as we compare the folks on the ground to the folks in the ivory tower as it can be mistaken as one is better than the other (or as you do in your writing here, position them at different points in the spectrum and show preference to one even as you yourself must partner with these very advocates to do the work you do). Thank you for sharing this as I often struggle to understand the point of research for research sake. I question my role as a faculty and how, if at all, educational research has made change in the past 2 decades. I am still having a hard time actually coming up with a single example of how educational research was "correct". So, I am glad others are thinking and writing about it as well (even if I don't completely agree).
Advocacy Fatigue: It Should Be a Thing | APALA
December 28, 2014[…] who take seriously the charge of advocacy and activism within APALA and ALA. Many of us conduct scholarly activism, not just advocacy. Many of us immerse ourselves into scholarly, academic literature and are guided by theoretical […]
Usman Iftikhar
January 1, 2015As a graduate student, I heed your advice. Its crucial that all of us take action in the world of problems and be a part of social change. Thank you for everything you do!
Sol Gamsu
May 6, 2015[…] in the UK (see below however for at least one exception), though it is worth noting the director Sara Goldrick-Raab’s distinction between the ‘scholar-activist’ and advocacy-type roles of other politically engaged academics. Certainly her randomised-controlled trial-esque approach […]
Esanohar
December 10, 2019I never imagined in my life that I'd be connected to science. Research, the kind of laboratories, well, clearly not what I wanted. And then came the moment of choosing a profession, an educational institution. Long-term communication with relatives, half of whom work at the university is engaged in science, I think from my words it is already clear what I have started to do besides studying..... As the science of me, in fact, has attracted, time for study almost did not suffice.I searched for service which will help to solve problems with a writing of texts and here the purpose is reached https://phdessay.com/. The glow in my eyes, the joy of winning and the fatigue of wasting my time led me to the expected goal. Already a year at the university, and this site is always in the bookmark. And science and study, all together and actively.
pikachu
December 11, 2019I know there will be many difficulties and challenges but I am determined to do it. If it fails then it will also be a lesson for me. atari breakout
Grace Hudditon
December 30, 2019I do like this blog post. It is very cognitive. I used to check the articles at https://elitewritings.com/topic-generator.html. I will start visiting this site more often from today.
iob netbanking
January 19, 2020Thank you so much for proportion this sort of articles keeps the users hobby in this article, I simply like to study this high-quality weblog.
https://bit.ly/303moxf
gotiry
January 19, 2020Thank you so much for proportion this sort of articles keeps the users hobby in this article, I simply like to study this high-quality weblog.
iob netbanking
Manoj
February 11, 2020You are such a good blogger. We all should learn from you. https://downloadstatus.xyz/category/telugu/ I have developed this blog by inspiring you.
Manoj
February 11, 2020You are such a good blogger. We all should learn from you. https://downloadstatus.xyz/category/telugu I have developed this blog by inspiring you.
STATUS BHANDAR
June 3, 2020very good information
for whatsapp status videos
https://www.statusbhandar.in/
STATUS BHANDAR
June 3, 2020https://www.statusbhandar.in/
STATUS BHANDAR
June 3, 2020very good information
for whatsapp status videos
https://www.statusbhandar.in/
Gujarati Blog
July 11, 2020Gujarati Blog
Aakash Portal is one of the best gujarati online blog that provides various fields knowledge in religion language
umesh
July 21, 2020you have a great content and writing type is just amazing please check my site also
Info Exam Jyot
August 30, 2020Info Exam Jyot is Provids Best Budgets gadgets Under 1000
sona
September 6, 2020also chake rain whatsapp status video download
statussove
September 15, 2020Nice, visit to get the best Whatsapp status
jey00
September 15, 2020Get the best Whatsapp status in English at statussove
Ujjain Cab
September 16, 2020Please check our books https://www.ujjaincab.com/
jeevan
September 16, 2020Please check our Books
jey00
October 2, 2020Get news and updates at jsnewstimes
jimmy
October 5, 2020Nice, get the best Whatsapp status videos free download jsvidos
Status shop
October 25, 2020Wow, What an Outstanding post. I found this too much informatics. It is what I was seeking for.
I found this too much informatics. It is what I was seeking for. I would like to recommend you that please keep sharing such type of info.If possible, Thanks.
mestatusvideo
November 7, 2020lovely New status video
mestatusvideo
November 7, 2020New Sambalpuri Whatsapp status video to express your sad ,love feeling to your girlfriend on your status like whatsapp status video download
me2lovestory
November 8, 2020love story shayari Matty J & laura B The Bachelor romantic love story in hindi
Ujjain to Omkareshwar taxi
April 5, 2021Thank you So Much This Article Sharing With Us keep it up.
Purandar Satnami
April 17, 2021nice
Faiz
November 20, 2021Nice Article
rahul001
December 5, 2021Thanks for sharing this information is great and useful
Surjendu Tommy
December 15, 2021Thanks for posting such posts here.
Surjendu Bhadra
December 18, 2021Good work friend I read some articles that you posted in your blog. I just want to admire blog and your work. Thanks for posting such posts here.
Wishingdays
June 22, 2023Nice blog
Tariro Tandi
September 18, 2023As a scholar-activist who found herself like a fish out of water when I embarked on my Communication and media Ph.D. after 14 years of working with social justice movements, I appreciate your blog. I can't just engage in research for the sake of research; it has ultimately contributed to improving the lives of those who are marginalized in communities. There is a need to bridge the gap between theory in academia and people's lived realities for all that research to be relevant.
madhur matka
September 28, 2023Scholarly activism plays a crucial role in shaping our world. It's about using knowledge, research, and expertise to drive positive change and address pressing issues. When scholars step out of the ivory tower and engage with real-world problems, they can make a profound impact. It's inspiring to see academics committed to making the world a better place through their work. Keep pushing boundaries and challenging the status quo.
Sattalal
October 8, 2023Scholarly activism is the true embodiment of knowledge in action! It's about harnessing the power of intellect and research to drive positive change in our society. Kudos to all the scholars who are not just confined to ivory towers but are actively shaping a better world through their work. Your dedication inspires us all.
madhur matka