Fearless Girl: Seriously, The Guy Has a Point

Reprinted with permission.

I got metaphorically spanked a couple of days ago. Folks have been talking about the Fearless Girl statue ever since it was dropped in Manhattan’s Financial District some five weeks ago. I have occasionally added a comment or two to some of the online discussions about the statue.

Recently most of the Fearless Girl discussions have focused on the complaints by Arturo Di Modica, the sculptor who created Charging Bull. He wants Fearless Girl removed, and that boy is taking a metric ton of shit for saying that. Here’s what I said that got me spanked:

The guy has a point.

This happened in maybe three different discussions over the last week or so. In each case I explained briefly why I believe Di Modica has a point (and I’ll explain it again in a bit), and for the most part folks either accepted my comments or ignored them. Which is pretty common for online discussions. But in one discussion my comment sparked this:

Men who don’t like women taking up space are exactly why we need the Fearless Girl.

Which — and this doesn’t need to be said, but I’m okay with saying the obvious — is a perfectly valid response. It’s also one I agree with. As far as that goes, it’s one NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio agrees with, since he said it first (although, to be fair, probably one of his public relations people first said it first).

But here’s the thing: you can completely agree with the woman who responded to my comment AND you can still acknowledge that Arturo Di Modica has a point. Those aren’t mutually exclusive or contradictory points of view.

Let me apologize here, because I have to do some history — and for reasons I’ve never understood, some folks actively dislike history. It’s necessary though. So here we go. Back in 1987 there was a global stock market crash. Doesn’t matter why (at least not for this discussion), but stock markets everywhere — everywhere — tanked. Arturo Di Modica, a Sicilian immigrant who became a naturalized citizen of the U.S., responded by creating Charging Bull — a bronze sculpture of a…well, a charging bull. It took him two years to make it. The thing weighs more than 7000 pounds, and cost Di Modica some US$350,000 of his own money. He said he wanted the bull to represent “the strength and power of the American people”. He had it trucked into the Financial District and set it up, completely without permission. It’s maybe the only significant work of guerrilla capitalist art in existence.

People loved it. The assholes who ran the New York Stock Exchange, for some reason, didn’t. They called the police, and pretty soon the statue was removed and impounded. A fuss was raised, the city agreed to temporarily install it, and the public was pleased. It’s been almost thirty years, and Charging Bull is still owned by Di Modica, still on temporary loan to the city, still one of the most recognizable symbols of New York City.

And that brings us to March 7th of this year, the day before International Women’s Day. Fearless Girl appeared, standing in front of Charging Bull. On the surface, it appears to be another work of guerrilla art — but it’s not. Unlike Di Modica’s work, Fearless Girl was commissioned. Commissioned not by an individual, but by an investment fund called State Street Global Advisors, which has assets in excess of US$2.4 trillion. That’s serious money. It was commissioned as part of an advertising campaign developed by McCann, a global advertising corporation. And it was commissioned to be presented on the first anniversary of State Street Global’s “Gender Diversity Index” fund, which has the following NASDAQ ticker symbol: SHE. And finally, along with Fearless Girl is a bronze plaque that reads:

Know the power of women in leadership. SHE makes a difference.

Note it’s not She makes a difference, it’s SHE makes a difference. It’s not referring to the girl; it’s referring to the NASDAQ symbol. It’s not a work of guerrilla art; it’s an extremely clever advertising scheme. This is what makes it clever: Fearless Girl derives its power almost entirely from Di Modica’s statue. The sculptor, Kristen Visbal, sort of acknowledges this. She’s said this about her statue:

“She’s not angry at the bull — she’s confident, she knows what she’s capable of, and she’s wanting the bull to take note.”

It’s all about the bull. If it were placed anywhere else, Fearless Girl would still be a very fine statue — but without facing Charging Bull the Fearless Girl has nothing to be fearless to. Or about. Whatever. Fearless Girl, without Di Modica’s bull, without the context provided by the bull, becomes Really Confident Girl.

Fearless Girl also changes the meaning of Charging Bull. Instead of being a symbol of “the strength and power of the American people” as Di Modica intended, it’s now seen as an aggressive threat to women and girls — a symbol of patriarchal oppression.

In effect, Fearless Girl has appropriated the strength and power of Charging Bull. Of course Di Modica is outraged by that. A global investment firm has used a global advertising firm to create a faux work of guerrilla art to subvert and change the meaning of his actual work of guerrilla art. That would piss off any artist.

See? It’s not as simple as it seems on the surface. It’s especially complicated for somebody (like me, for example) who appreciates the notion of appropriation in art. I’ve engaged in a wee bit of appropriation my ownself. Appropriation art is, almost by definition, subversive — and subversion is (also almost by definition) usually the province of marginalized populations attempting to undermine the social order maintained by tradition and the establishments of power. In the case of Fearless Girl, however, the subversion is being done by global corporatists as part of a marketing campaign. That makes it hard to cheer them on. There’s some serious irony here.

And yet, there she is, the Fearless Girl. I love the little statue of the girl in the Peter Pan pose. And I resent that she’s a marketing tool. I love that she actually IS inspiring to young women and girls. And I resent that she’s a fraud. I love that she exists. And I resent the reasons she was created.

I love the Fearless Girl and I resent her. She’s an example of how commercialization can take something important and meaningful — something about which everybody should agree — and shit all over it by turning it into a commodity. Fearless Girl is beautiful, but she is selling SHE; that’s why she’s there.

Should Fearless Girl be removed as Di Modica wants? I don’t know. It would be sad if she was. Should Di Modica simply take his Charging Bull and go home? I mean, it’s his statue. He can do what he wants with it. I couldn’t blame him if he did that, since the Fearless Girl has basically hijacked the meaning of his work. But that would be a shame. I’m not a fan of capitalism, but that’s a damned fine work of art.

I don’t know what should be done here. But I know this: Arturo Di Modica has a point. And I know a lot of folks aren’t willing to acknowledge that.

Greg Fallis is a writer and photographer who has, from time to time, taught sociology and criminology at the American University and Fordham University. He is the managing editor of Utata.org and teaches advanced workshops in Mystery Writing for the Gotham Writers’ Workshop.

Comments 13

Glire Weatherwax

May 4, 2017

I'm willing to acknowledge that di Modica has a point. And someone who interprets this installation the way he has isn't wrong, I don't think.

But speaking of appropriation, "Fearless Girl" has been instantly appropriated away from its intended message. Nobody I've spoken to about "Fearless Girl" was aware of the fact that an investment firm has done the installation, and for them, it's a powerful symbol of the role of women in protesting the worst excesses of the financial sector.

The fact that the statue was supposed to advertise an index fund is kind of besides the point. In the mind of the public, it's not about that, and never was. And for that matter, regardless of the intent of di Modica, the intended message of "Charging Bull" is just as lost: For many people, it represents the raging greed of the banking industry. The obvious narrative in the current cultural context of the two statues completely overrides the meaning those two statues were supposed to have, and, speaking for myself alone, I think this new statue deserves the same fate as the bull did in 1987 -- keep it there, because of its widespread popularity as a symbol to rally around. Its meaning as that kind of symbol may not have been intended, but it's certainly there now, and I don't think it's a net benefit to take that symbol away now that it's there.


May 5, 2017

was not there when when bull charged. am not there when girl abandoned fear. but know from here that she didnt. she got whispered on her ear "be strong, we got money and we support you, by being fearless you inspire others, and they're less afraid of us, more afraid of the bull" by spooks. not my place to say should either of them stay or go. dont know. but to me it remains clear lots of folks draw strenght from that. worrying times if thats the case, desperate times; its bull should be afraid.


September 29, 2017

very good


October 18, 2018

This way we can get the golf clash hack and that is the best way anyone can get the gems.


November 16, 2018

Play best and interesting online game coolmaths accept the game challenge and hit the target to play the game go to the portal.

tom handil

November 13, 2019

Yeah, Hopefully, a fearless girl be to be a better women and then turns into an Example of mom. Mothers are likely very curies about their love once, Thier Childers and the whole family. https://99fictions.com/missing-mom-quotes/


June 1, 2020

I love to read this article about the fearless girl. And i also glad to know about his me reviews. I also visit here on regularly basis and got always new information. So, now you can check https://essayguru.org/essay-help to prepare their exam. Wow, this is literally phenomenal from him. Incredible

pikachu chu

July 22, 2020

There are many websites for you to find places you need to visit, but you should visit this site. I think you will not be disappointed. mapquest driving directions

best toys

September 15, 2020

Which sex toys choose? Check out the best sex toys go to our site and find more here.

suka min

September 23, 2020

There are many websites for you to visit to find many places, you should try to visit here: bmi calculator

enney Beverly

September 23, 2020

Why do you think so many American men want to buy Asian bride? It’s because men are sick and tired of independent and feminist women. Western ladies are all about money, career, and rights. Unfortunately, they don’t understand that they turn men off by wanting to be so “I can do everything myself”.Thai and Filipino girls are the most popular among Western men. The highest percentage of Westerners who got married to women from Asian are actually married to women from Thailand and the Philippines. Ladies from these two countries mail order japanese brides seem to make perfect wives for American bachelors. They look stunning and they have a lot of positive qualities that attract men

Tiffany Walls

November 9, 2020

College essay writing services can be a terrific aid in writing the perfect essay. https://customwriteonline.com gives people a chance to employ expert essay authors who can help them write an essay for the examinations, because of their high school jobs or for additional papers that they need to complete for college. There are various companies which offer essay writing solutions so one should make certain to choose the one that can provide them the very best and most effective results in writing an essay

Tiffany Walls

November 9, 2020

College essay writing services can be a terrific aid in writing the perfect essay. Custom Write Online gives people a chance to employ expert essay authors who can help them write an essay for the examinations, because of their high school jobs or for additional papers that they need to complete for college. There are various companies which offer essay writing solutions so one should make certain to choose the one that can provide them the very best and most effective results in writing an essay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *